| Claudia/Stacey are BFFS | Jamie Newton | Claudia has her own phone line | Mimi's Accent | Kristy is a control freak |
| Stacey is from NYC | Massive Pike brood | Claudia's Art | A club member yells at a club member | Watson's a millionaire |
| Mary Anne wants to live in NYC | Karen's imagination | THE BABY-SITTERS CLUB BINGO (BOOKS 1-4) BINGO (free square) | Claudia's flawless skin | Mary Anne's braids |
| Kristy/Mary Anne are BFFS | Morbidda Destiny | "Cool" accessories--Claudia | Mary Anne's dad is strict | Claudia's Junk Food Addiction |
| Stacey has Diabetes | MWF at 5:30 | Janine is a Genius | "Cool" accessories--Stacey | BSC was Kristy's idea |